ADC, along with Leading Free Speech Organizations, Challenge Court Ruling in Mohsen Mahdawi Case, Warning of Threat to First Amendment Rights of Millions of Noncitizens
FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE
November 16, 2026
[email protected]
Washington, D.C. | The American-Arab Anti-Discrimination Committee (ADC) filed an amicus brief before the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit on November 13, challenging a ruling that could effectively allow the federal government to detain noncitizens in retaliation for their protected political speech without timely judicial intervention. The Foundation for Individual Rights and Expression (FIRE), PEN America, the Rutherford Institute, and the National Coalition Against Censorship (NCAC), all signed on.
Mahdawi, a Palestine-born, U.S. permanent resident and Columbia University student, co-founded the university’s Palestinian Student Union and helped organize campus protests opposing Israel’s genocide in Gaza. On April 14, 2025, federal immigration agents arrested him during an appointment to complete the process of becoming a U.S. citizen. He spent 16 days in detention before a federal judge ordered his release.
A federal district court concluded that Mahdawi had raised a substantial First Amendment retaliation claim. However, on appeal, the Second Circuit panel held that the district court lacked jurisdiction to review his challenge to the detention before the conclusion of his immigration proceedings.
The brief argues that this reasoning fundamentally misunderstands the nature of the constitutional injury. Retaliatory detention and removal proceedings violate First Amendment rights, regardless of the ultimate outcome in immigration court. By postponing judicial review until the immigration process concludes, the government is permitted to inflict constitutional and psychological harm while simultaneously sending a chilling message to millions of noncitizens that their political expression may carry devastating consequences.
“The First Amendment was intentionally framed as a restraint on government. Its plain text is unconcerned with the citizenship status of the speaker, and for good reason. The Framers understood that free speech is a human right, and that societies flourish when all those living within them may speak their minds without retribution from government,” said Jenin Younes, ADC President and Legal Director. “Non-citizens do not forfeit their freedom of expression merely because they are subject to the government’s immigration authority. As another federal court recently reaffirmed, ‘Stated plainly, in the United States, freedom of speech belongs to the people. It is not the government’s to take.'”
The brief further warns that the consequences of retaliatory immigration enforcement extend far beyond any single individual. Citing federal court findings, it points to evidence that noncitizen journalists and contributors have withdrawn articles, refused assignments, requested anonymity, and refrained from speaking publicly out of fear of immigration consequences. This chilling effect begins when individuals are targeted for their protected expression, whether through detention, investigations, or removal proceedings, not merely when deportation ultimately occurs.
“The government cannot be permitted to imprison people for exercising their First Amendment rights and then tell them they must wait months or years for a federal court to hear their challenge,” said Malak Afaneh, ADC Staff Attorney and Counsel of Record for the amici. “Mohsen Mahdawi was confined in a 7-by-12-foot solitary cell for expressing political views protected by the Constitution. No court ruling months or years later can give him back that time, undo the suppression of his speech, or erase the fear instilled in millions of noncitizens who watched what happened to him. The First Amendment means little if the government can punish people for exercising it while denying them timely access to an independent federal court.”
The brief also challenges the notion that immigration proceedings can provide an adequate substitute for independent federal judicial review. Immigration courts operate under the Department of Justice, which is part of the same executive branch responsible for enforcing immigration law. Unlike independent federal judges, immigration judges and members of the Board of Immigration Appeals operate under the authority of the Attorney General, who has the power to remove immigration judges and review their decisions.
In Mahdawi’s own case, the Board of Immigration Appeals declined to consider his constitutional arguments or the lawfulness of his detention, deferring those issues until a potential appeal from a final removal order. The immigration judge who initially terminated his removal proceedings after finding that the government had failed to establish grounds for deportation was subsequently fired by the Department of Justice.
These circumstances, the brief argues, expose a fundamental flaw in requiring noncitizens to spend months or even years fighting their deportation through immigration hearings and appeals overseen by the federal government before they can bring their constitutional claims before an independent federal judge. During that time, the same government accused of punishing individuals for their protected speech can continue pursuing their detention and removal without a federal court determining whether those actions violate the First Amendment.
As the Supreme Court has long recognized, the loss of First Amendment freedoms, even for minimal periods, constitutes irreparable injury. A ruling issued months or years after an unlawful detention cannot restore the period during which political expression was suppressed, nor can it erase the fear inflicted on others who witnessed the government’s actions.
ADC and its co-signatories urge the full Second Circuit to affirm the district court’s authority to review Mahdawi’s independent First Amendment retaliation claim and reject an interpretation of federal immigration law that would leave constitutional violations without timely judicial redress.
The brief concludes by invoking the Supreme Court’s landmark declaration in West Virginia State Board of Education v. Barnette:
“If there is any fixed star in our constitutional constellation, it is that no official… can prescribe what shall be orthodox in politics.”
###
Recent Posts
Action Alerts
Your support means everything. Your gift protects rights, builds community, and fights hate. Let’s move forward together.